Design Reasoning Without Explanationsas anDesign ReasoningWithout Explanations
نویسنده
چکیده
design? The most immediate impact would be expected in the area of improved tools and environments for designers. The tools might ultimately include resource material to facilitate decision making, such as textbooks, guides, codes, and computer programs. Environments might ultimately be systems of organization and communication that are tuned to the needs of designers. However, the most important category within tools and environments is essentially of a different character. I refer here to the contribution of design research to the intellectual resources that facilitate discourse about design. Thus, one of the most important spin-offs from design research is the sets of terms, models, intellectual structures and, ultimately, the controversies that enable us to talk about design. We might suppose that design would still successfully occur without these intellectual structures, as it does in many cultures today. Furthermore, insights could be expected to arise from the deliberations of design practitioners and critics whose activities do not come under the heading of research. However, there is obvious merit in articulating design, separating it from other concerns, and making it an object of study and carefully reasoned reflection. The resulting intellectual structures would be expected to benefit the fostering of design ability, both formally in design schools and as designers respond to their environment and each other. Thus, the products of design research are inexorably linked with design education. The goals of design research are varied, and the sources of its methods of inquiry are diverse, calling on such areas as history, hermeneutics, sociology, psychology, philosophy, and computing. Irrespective of the genre within which the research is undertaken, we can legitimately ask, How does design research impinge on This article proposes connectionism as an alternative to classical cognitivism in understanding design. Articles
منابع مشابه
Computing Design Rationales Using Causal Representation of Simulations
We present a new system for computing design rationales of geometric features on mechanical devices. Our system interprets dynamic simulations of mechanical devices and automatically generates an English text document for the purposes of the geometric features on the device. To identify the purpose of a particular feature, we simulate the behavior of the device with and without the feature pres...
متن کاملTowards a hypothetical learning progression of scientific explanation
The construction of scientific explanations, as a key scientific practice, has been highlighted in policy documents. However, research suggests that students lack competence in constructing scientific explanations and this is due to a lack of appropriate scaffolding in science instruction. To address this problem, researchers have developed the Claim-Evidence-Reasoning framework, as scaffolding...
متن کاملA DSL for Explaining Probabilistic Reasoning
We propose a new focus in language design where languages provide constructs that not only describe the computation of results, but also produce explanations of how and why those results were obtained. We posit that if users are to understand computations produced by a language, that language should provide explanations to the user. As an example of such an explanation-oriented language we pres...
متن کاملA Design of a Configurable Feature Model Configurator
Our feature configuration tool ST 2 Configurator integrates (1) a visual interactive representation of the feature model and (2) a formal reasoning engine that calculates consequences of the user’s actions and provides formal explanations. The tool’s software architecture is designed as a chain of components, which provide mappings between visual elements and their corresponding formal represen...
متن کاملExplanations and Case-Based Reasoning in Ambient Intelligent Systems
Interacting with intelligent systems in general and ambient intelligent systems in particular, requires that these systems have the ability to build a trust relationship with the users. The ability to explain its own behaviour is one of the most important abilities that such a system can exhibit to gain trust. We argue that explanations are not just an addition to an ambient intelligent system ...
متن کامل